Season 32 Top 10 Trade Acquisitions
With trades you always have winners and losers, so what players that have swapped franchises this year have proven to be wins for their teams? Ewell Priest It should come as no shock that the best player traded this offseason has had the biggest impact. For Columbus, Priest has done what he has always done – mash the baseball. He is hitting .310/.360/.529 with 27 homeruns so far. Not all of Columbus’ moves have panned out the way they had hoped this offseason, but Priest will pay off for a long time. Juan Owen San Fransisco was looking to fill a lot of hole under new management and they needed some offensive punch at the ML level. While they may not have turned around their squad this season, acquiring Juan Owen has certainly panned out for them. Owen is hitting .283 with a .384 OBP with 19 homeruns, 22 doubles, and 20 stolen bases. He has provided the kind of consistency this franchise desperately needed this offseason. Rigo Goya Losing Boomer Hoffman in free agency left Toledo with a hole in their rotation and they thought Goya would fit nicely after a down year last season. He has responded well to the change of scenery, going 15-5 with a 3.70 ERA and providing some veteran stability that Toledo believed they needed to make another run at a title. Yonder Diaz The play of Diaz has made Mexico City the winners of the Diaz/Pan for Matthew Carroll swap. Diaz is above his career averages in average, OBP, and slugging percentage (.270/.342/ .461), already has a career high of 23 home runs, and has stolen 30 bags. Those numbers could yield Diaz a nice contract in free agency. Arthur Mattingly A speedster like Mattingly has to hate leaving a stolen base free for all like Las Vegas, but Vegas needed to shed salary and Toledo needed a bat for their bench in order to make Juan Owen expendable. It has proven to be an important trade for Toledo as Mattingly was originally slotted in a bench role but has moved into a full time 2B and leadoff man. Filling that role has been more pivotal than his production which has been average (.267/.329 with 48 stolen bases). Jeff Leary Leary was a bit of a throw in player, but he has proven to be an impact platoon player for Montreal at catcher. He is hitting.271 with a career high 28 homeruns and is part of the reason Montreal has moved into a potential wild card spot. Matthew Carroll Carroll was one of the bigger names moved in the offseason and everyone in Columbus hoped he would live up to his potential and promise. But no one thinks Carroll is delivering the way Columbus had hoped for. He is hitting above his career averages though at .258/.325/.416, has a career high 20 stolen bases, and 18 home runs – one away from tying his career high. While he may not be what everyone hoped, but having his first 20-20 season and becoming one fo the best defensive 3B in the NL ranks this as a solid acquisition. Now we get to some of the midseason swaps… Javier Arroyo El Paso had been searching for an impact starting pitcher all season and when Arroyo became available in Honolulu, they pounced. Arroyo has given them a great second option, going 8-3 with a 2.87 WHIP. Arroyo may not have been enough to propel them into the wildcard this year, but he may have been what they needed to take that step next season. Omar Lopez Honolulu was looking to add depth when they traded Arroyo, and they not only added that but are getting the same kind of production out of one of the 3 pitchers they got back in Lopez. Lopez is 8-2 pitching for the islanders with a 3.45 ERA. His numbers are far better than the rest of his career has shown, but so far Honolulu doesn’t miss Arroyo at all. Carlos Balboa Balboa has not pitched a lot and he won’t pitch a lot, but when he has pitched, he has done it well. In 13 games, he has a 1.69 ERA and has only walked one batter. Balboa won’t be a workhorse, but he may provided Ottawa with some great matchup opportunities come playoff time.
So I’ve recently been using Twitter (as a Cavs fan, I was among the Twitter obsessed during the Lebron James saga and it hooked me) and I’ve found that 140 characters sometimes is pretty difficult for me. But when you are trying to say something meaningful (because that’s what social media is all about, meaningful thought), 140 characters forces you to focus in on what’s important. So it gave me the idea to try this out for the BSA blog and since I never have the time to do a full on season preview, let’s do it in 140 character per team. I will order the teams in my prediction of where they will end the season and write a highlight, question, or thought about their upcoming season in 140 characters or less. Oh, and you don’t even have to follow me @vzweeks to get these tweets!
1. Burlington Ents – Eugenio Sosa signing an extension was the most shocking move of this offseason. Losing Patrick Lewis hurts but still the favorite in the NL
2. Montreal Tim Raine’s – Always has a surprise in this division and the additions of SP B. Hoffman and D. Hernandez could revive baseball in Canada #whendoesNHLstart
3. Columbus Script – Adding Priest and Carroll were great moves, but they really need another starting pitcher or two to make a run at a World Series return
4. Augusta Warriors – Is their anyway Juan Park can pitch too? And someone find out where the John Clark of 4 seasons ago disappeared to
1. Richmond Poes – Jeff Rogers and Sadie Grim need to step it up for Richmond to become title contenders. Patrick Lewis signing provides needed stability
2. Toledo Black Sheep – The decline begins with the loss of Hoffman. Still a contender come playoff time, but win total will drop this season and even more next
3. Cincinnati Communists – Queen City left staring north at Toledo yet again #Ohiogeography Should see an improved record from the Commies, maybe a run at .500
4. Washington D.C. Huskies – Tike Henson will fit right into the DC culture #chicsdigthelongball Still searching for someone to step it up and break out in the rotation
1. Mexico City Sombreros – Hardest division to pick, but the most talent resides in Mexico City. Oliver Blanks has to live up to potential for this team to contend
2. Tampa Bay Tritons – Unamuno and Thompson are the new wave of talent Tamp has pinned its hopes to, but it needs pitching to move back to the top
3. Austin City Limits – Could have the best pitching in the division which might push them above 85 wins and into the driver’s seat of division. Soto could explode
4. New Orleans Swim – New ownership will have to decide what it is going to do with all its young talent, which could easily push them towards the top of division
1. San Diego SAMCRO – Andrea Parker had a really down year last year but still got a huge extension. He needs to be an anchor in the order #breakoutseason
2. Honolulu Noka Oi – Need Javier Arroyo to pitch like he did in s30 and Enerio Fuentes to cash in on his potential to really emerge into true contender status
3. Los Angeles Freaks – Jamison is a good signing, but team is aging with no pitching, so they’ll need angels in the outfield to get into the race #signtonydanza
4. San Fransisco Sequoias – Owen and Purcell improve the top of the lineup and should make the youngsters better but the lack of pitching depth will keep them down
1. Ottawa Pride – Mitch Morehead and Trot Harmon were the best free agent haul of anyone and should keep Ottawa at the top, but end of dominance is coming
2. Scranton Skeddadlers – This youth has to mature eventually, right? Galahad Morris is the key to this team moving from potential promise to the promised land
3. Trenton Twins – Losing Morehead hurts, but adding Alfonseca and Yamamoto helps make up for it. Needs more offensive punch somewhere from the lineup
4. Vancouver Vipers – Vancouver has some young talent but still lacks any kind of starting pitching to move above .500. Do have the best curling squad in the BSA
1. Huntington Catholics – Early contender for AL World Series representative. Pitching looks good but should add another bat to really be a contender #CansecoforMVP
2. Boston Bombers – 2 first ballot HOFers (Coleridge, Sherman) on the pitching staff with a third potential candidate (Guerrero), any life left? #retirementhome
3. Pittsburgh Ghosts – Huston Thurston and Luis Arias are desperate to get out of AAA and show the world what they can do on the big stage. Rosado contract stings
4. Baltimore Fire – Antithesis of Boston with a stunning youth movement (and more is coming), but the young talent is not yet ready to translate into wins
2. El Paso Border Patrol – Was Steve Laffey overhyped or will he move closer to the force he was can be? It’s a battle for second place #anythingcanhappenintheplayoffs
3. Charlote Panthers – Frank Burton is still a stud, but he can’t carry this team into the playoffs. Fans are clamoring for Albert Donahue
4. Kansas City Monarchs – Is this Thames last go around for the Monarchs? Will the front office look to move Piper? Any gas left in Ramirez? Lots of questions in KC
1. St. Louis Brown Stockings – Rebuild is officially over. Amassed loads of young pitching talent and several promising hitters. Could be a candidate for a huge trade
2. Las Vegas Spittin Vermin – Mickey McGuire could top to 1000 stolen base mark this season, a remarkable feat that will probably never be truly appreciated properly
3. Fresno Reds – Orval Farley should hit the majors this season, but they are still in talent acquisition mode and will be for a few more seasons
4. Colorado Dusters – Tony Castro and Joaquin Amaral finally give the Colorado fans something worth watching, but they want to know when Takada is coming too
To start, I believe all of the following players could have a case made for them to be placed in the Hall of Fame (n0t that they all belong, but that a case could be made):
Tony Bonilla, Philip Buford, Johnnie Bush Luis Canseco, Toby Darnell, Odalis Franco, Rafael Franco, Andruw Hartzell, Kevin Lim, Al Lunar, R.J. Milton, Eduardo Mota, Ernie Price, Shawn Radlosky, Edwin Saveur, Felix Sexton, Juan Tavarez
Here is my ballot:
- Andruw Hartzell – Hartzell accomplished a rare offensive feat in his career in finishing with career averages above. 300 batting average, .400 OBP, and .500 slugging. While 473 homeruns is not an eye popping number in this game, he has nearly 3000 hits, (#4 all time), and 483 doubles which shows he did have that extra base power and wasn’t just a singles hitter. Not to mention that he played almost all of his career in the hitter’s death trap of Tacoma. With all of those factors, Hartzell is one of the best all around hitters to ever play in the BSA and deserves a HOF plaque.
- Kevin Lim – Lim was not the all around hitter Hartzell was, but he could hit the long ball with the best of them. With 687 home runs and over 1800 RBI, Lim is the kind of power hitter Hall fo Fame visitors expect to see.
- Odalis Franco – Franco is pretty much a carbon copy of Lim. His power numbers are just a little behind him and he lacks an MVP award, but he did have a better average, OBP, and slugging percentage along with more doubles and over 2500 hits. I think Franco has waited long enough and is ready to punch his ticket to Montana (that is where the BSA hall of fame is, right?)
- Shawn Radlosky – Radlosky was as consistent a starter as anyone could hope for. With over 250 wins, he ranks among the top 10 all time. Looking at pithers already in the Hall of Fame, Radlosky compares to Mitch Singleton (he’s actually better than him in every major category). Radlosky is another who has paid his dues waiting around and his time is due to receive the acknowledgement that he deserves.
- Toby Darnell – The 5th spot is always the hardest as there are always a number of deserving candidates and this is the guy you end up comparing them all to. I have been voting for Darnell for a few years for a couple of reasons. First, I regard him as a second baseman and in that light, he is offensive output is impressive. While he didn’t quite get to 400 home runs, his slugging percentage is above .500, and he hit above .300 with over 2500 hits. He’s a top all time hitter in the BSA.
If we could extend our ballots to 10 votes like the MLB hall, this would be the rest of mine in order:
- Rafael Franco – DH and durability aside, this guy could flat out mash.
- Juan Tavarez – More wins would have made him a shoe in
- Luis Canseco – and underrated and overlooked all around hitter
- Ernie Price – 2 MVPS alone puts him here
- Felix Sexton – One of the top offensive threats from shortstop ever
1. Ahmad Nippert (San Diego) ****1/2- This 18 year old lefty is dominate against left handed hitters and can really give the radar gun a workout. A potential top of the line starter is everything a rebuilding team would want in the first pick.
2. J.O. Chavez (Baltimore) **** – May not be a dominant starter, but has 3 good pitches and could really be a workhorse.
3. Damion Wilkins (Scranton) ***** – As if Scranton didn’t have enough great prospects already, they walk away with a a middle infielder who has a decent glove and a could be a perennial league leader in batting average and even has some pop and speed to go with it.
4. Darin Barker (New Orleans) ****1/2 – You don’t see first baseman picked in the top 5 of the draft anymore, unless of course they hit like Barker. Huge power and everything else to go with it.
5. Ryuu Hasegawa (Baltimore) **** – About as good of a hitting second baseman as you could find, his range could develop enough to make him a possible centerfielder.
6. Darrell Grey (Mexico City) *** – He’ll have to move from SS, but he could play almost anywhere else. Health concerns are the huge knock against him
7. Eugene Lillibridge (Fargo) – unsigned
8. Chipper Mlicki (Scottsdale) **** – His eye is the only knock on this corner outfielder, but he’ll still hit just fine.
9. Addison Wilson (Vancouver) ** 1/2 – He’d have a decent bat for a SS, but his range isn’t good enough to play SS.
10. Benjamin Thurman (Honolulu) *** – Thurman is a SS with a decent bat and the range. His throwing accuracy is a little lacking, but he could be one of the better all around short stops in the league.
11. Al Hernandez (Austin) ***1/2 – A lefty starter who struggles a little against righties, but he can dial it up on the radar gun with superior control.
12. Harry Cruz ( Cincinnati) – unsigned
13. Sammy Serra (Rochester) *** – While his splits are average and his health is a little low for some owner’s comfort, his control combined with his velocity and pitches will make him a solid ML starter if he stays healthy.
14. Jim Kingman (Trenton) ***1/2 – A solid second baseman with a good eye who could make a solid leadoff hitter with his eye and speed, though his durability will hold him back a little at the top of the order.
15. Turk West (Charlotte) *** – He’s not going to be a top of the rotation starter, but with great control and 4 good pitches, he can be a workhorse middle of the rotation type.
16. Murray Kiner (LA) ***1/2 – Another great leadoff candidate with low durability, he could be a little like Otto Buchanon.
17. Cookie Bautista (Tampa Bay) – unsigned
18. Nash Bonham (El Paso) *** – Might have the best combination of pitches in the draft. His major issue is his durability, but he’ll be good when he does pitch.
19. Albert Donahue (Charlotte) ***1/2 – Big power particularly against righties, but he’ll be more than just a platoon player.
20. Bryant Ramirez (Las Vegas) ** – The first reliever taken in the draft, he shows a great fastball but doesn’t project to have the tools it takes to be a great closer.
21. Joe Quinn (Huntington) *** – The second reliever taken does have all the tools to be a closer in the league, though his stamina will limit his real impact.
22. Adam Teut (Toledo) ***1/2 – A really solid all around SP with a flamethrower for a right arm, but durability and health questions dropped him in the draft.
23. Jimmy Sosa (Nashville) – unsigned
24. Al Whitehill (Huntington) **1/2 – Another SS who will probably be moved, he could be a CF with a lot of power and a good eye though his splits will hold him back.
25. Santo Mendoza (Richmond) *** 1/2 – A finesse pitcher, he is a solid all around starter who can work the corner against righties and lefties.
26. Mack Parker (Tampa Bay) ** – It’ll be interesting to see where he actually ends up in the field, but his bat will be average wherever though his arm will be among the best at whatever position he does play.
27. Jake Arenado (Kansas City) *** – A solid defensive 2B with the range to possibly move to CF, has a solid all around bat that excels against south paws.
28. Houston Braden (Tampa Bay) *** – A solid reliever prospect with a rare 3 pitch combination that are all out piches.
29. A.J. White (Nashville) ** – A good eye and speed, he’ll have to move to a corner outfield spot and doesn’t have the bat to hold that spot.
30. Evan Snodgress (Portland) *** – This setup prospect will throw between 100 to 150 innings per season with his combination of skills.
31. Carlos Feliz (San Fransisco) ** – He has some solid splits, but his weak eye and poor range are what will hold him back.
32. Damian Hoover (Augusta) *** – If he doesn’t get hurt, he should make a great platoon player against lefties who could leadoff
33. Kirk West (Trenton) ***1/2 – A DH who could catch if he had to, he has the bat to be a major league hitter even if he didn’t own a glove. Struggles against righties some and his health is a concern, but a great pick at 33.
34. Bono Post (Toledo) **** – I might be biased with this assessment, but Post is a legitimate centerfielder with gold glove level range who can play everyday, has plus speed, and can put the ball in play well.
35. Denny Corbett (Ottawa) ***1/2 – The rich get richer as he may be the best closer prospect of the draft, but his health scared away a lot of teams.
I’ve had a hard time finding the time to blog for this season, but what better way to start off the New Year than with some blogging. We’re down to the wire, so what better way to start than with a playoff preview. I’ll take a look at each division and then the 2 wild card races. Honestly, there really is only one division that is even potentially a race, so I’ll highlight the ups and downs of each team.
AL North It is no surprise that defending champion Ottawa has run away with the division once again. While they are slightly behind last year’s pace , Ottawa is still the clear favorite to win it all, but they are aging so their grip on the AL may not last long. Vancouver took a step forward with their young hitters Alan Twitchell, Doyle Byrnes, and Carlos Viriato and have a chance to end a 7 season playoff drought. Trenton continues to hover around .500 but Mitch Morehead (13 wins, 2.99 ERA) continues to excel. Scranton continues to be at the bottom of the division, but their youth movement is starting and they’ll be at the top of this division soon. If their winning percentage holds up, they will have their highest win total in 16 seasons.
AL East Boston hasn’t wrapped up their 3rd straight division title, but they have a comfortable 7 game lead. Mendy Wingo is having a Cy Young caliber season for them, sitting at 15-5, 2.35 ERA, and .97 WHIP. Huntington is still in it, but something significant would have to happen since they have no games left with Boston. Brian Canseco has quietly been putting together one of his best seasons (.347/.450/.538) in his first season in Huntington. Rochester and Baltimore are both rebuilding, but both are playing better this year than last year and are showing some signs of life.
AL South Nashville is looking like a sure bet to repeat as division champs in what is normally one of the tightest division races. Sonny Torres has been out of his mind this season, pacing Nashville at 13-3. Charlotte is hanging in the wild card race with a balanced rotation that has 4 pitchers with double digit wins. Kansas City looked old at times this year, though Marvin Piper still showed himself as one of the best slugging catchers in BSA history with 33 long balls so far with 98 RBI. El Paso simply hasn’t gotten the production it expected out of some of their big free agents signings the past 2 seasons like Terrell Hoffman
AL West The AL West has always been a very competitive division with a tight race, but that was normally because it always had 3 good teams. They’re still competitive, but absent those 3 good teams. It looks like it is Las Vegas’ division to lose. Mikey McGuire needs 8 more stolen bases to become the 2nd player in the BSA with 800 stolen bases and 27 more to take the all time lead in the most neglected and forgotten category. San Fransisco is hanging around in the division title race, and a Ben Sherman led rotation could give them enough to not only take the division but pull an upset in the playoffs. After a surprising run last season, Portland has fallen back to earth, hitting only .232 as a team. Scottsdale continues the rebuilding effort after years at the top, but at least fans have Brian Kim to watch each night.
AL Wild Card While last season’s AL playoff race was a mess to figure out, this year really comes down to a 3 team race for the 2 wild card spots. Huntington stands at the top of the Wild Card race, 2 games ahead of Vancouver and 3 ahead of Charlotte. Huntington has been hot lately, winning 13 of 17, and has a fairly easy schedule ahead of them. Charlotte will play the 4 teams with the best records in the AL still, and Vancouver will need to gain ground early as it meets Nashville and Ottawa and the end of the season. But this week a 7 game stretch is coming up where Huntington plays 4 against Vancouver and then 3 against Charlotte which should really decide this race. I predict Huntington will all but secure their spot in that stretch and that Charlotte will squeeze out the final wild card spot the last days of the season while Vancouver is visiting Ottawa.
NL North This has been the best division in the NL for some time, and while that still holds true this season, it’s not the same. Burlington is in control and for the first time in years has breathing room down the stretch. Rudy Tabaka isn’t having as good a season as last year, but he set a ridiculous standard and is well on his way to another Cy Young with 20 wins, a 1.60 ERA, and a .86 WHIP. Columbus has stepped up this season and the trade for Tike Henson has pushed them into the playoff hunt with his .294 average and 25 homers. Augusta collapsed at the start of this season in surprising fashion, but they played more like the real Augusta in the second half and are making a mad dash towards the playoffs. Fargo has to hate being in this division, but Junior Manuel likes being in Fargo, putting up his 2nd straight 30 dinger season.
NL East While it was a close race early in the season, Toledo has pulled away with a comfortable 15 game lead. Juan Veras has proven worth the trade to get him, with 11 wins and a 2.31 ERA and 1.03 WHIP in Toledo. After taking a step forward into the playoff race last season, Richmond is playing at a slightly better place and in the driver’s seat for the second wild card spot. Veteran starter Philip Coleridge is still the heart beat of the team, just getting his 260th career victory. Washington has taken a little step back from last year, but is still slugging away with 3 hitters already over 30 home runs. Cincinnati never recovered from the devastating injury to Miguel Romano and is going to have to have to take another look at the mystery of why they are not more competitive.
NL South New Orleans is holding on to a 5 game leas over Tampa Bay, and Harry Shirley has been the difference with his 15 wins in his return from losing all of last season to injury. Tampa Bay is still fighting for life though and Koji Ming ‘s emergence as a closer has helped them in a a lot of close games. Mexico City and Austin are at the bottom this season, but in this division they could easily find themselves at the top next season.
NL West Boise is poised to win its 5th division title in 6 seasons. Trot Harmon is on pace to have his first 40 home run season and Vince Nathan continues to take his special “vitamins” and has posted consecutive 30 home run seasons. Tony Ellis was signed to lead LA past Boise this season, but he has struggled in LA, hitting only .249. In it’s first season under new ownership, San Diego has shown marked improvement and young Andrea Parker continues to shown the potential to be a superstar. Honolulu knows it’s future is much brighter than its present and has a steady flow of young talent waiting to make its way to the big show.
NL Wild Card If you were to just look at the standings and the math, Columbus and Richmond look to have their wild card spots all but secured. But then you see Augusta looming 5 games back and you know that team can kick it into another gear and make a big run. In fact, they already have. August is 26-12 since the All Star break, but just look at who is left on their schedule: Boise, Toledo, Richmond, Washington, Columbus, and Burlington. That is 3 division leaders, including the top 2 teams, and the 3 other teams in the wild card race. If August does pull off this comeback, it may be the best in season turnaround ever in the BSA and they’ll look like the team to beat in the playoffs. Washington isn’t out of it either and a hot streak could see them knock Richmond out again and they have a decent enough schedule to get hot and make that run. Richmond is in Honolulu right now and then has 7 home games against San Diego and Tampa Bay. If they can beat up on these teams like they should, it could secure them a spot regardless of what Augusta and DC does. Columbus is in the driver’s seat and aside from back to back home series against Toledo and Burlington, they don’t have a playoff team left on their schedule. I think Columbus should feel pretty secure at this point, but with the way Augusta is playing, every wild card team has to make sure they don’t slip up against the teams they should beat.
1 Aaron Johns (L) 97.47 HUNTINGTON,
2 Dennis Hiro (R) 96.52 OTTAWA,
3 Rudy Tabaka (R) 96.10 BURLINGTON,
4 Brook Easley (L) 94.87 OTTAWA,
5 Edgar Matos (R) 93.29 NASHVILLE,
6 Tony Tanaka (R) 92.72 OTTAWA,
7 Ezequiel Perez (L) 92.54 HUNTINGTON,
8 Rodrigo Cabrera (R) 91.88 VANCOUVER,
9 Diego Ramirez (R) 91.26 KANSAS CITY,
10 Juan Veras (L) 91.00 HUNTINGTON,
11 Victor Guerra (L) 89.66 OTTAWA,
12 Joaquin Guerrero (R) 88.99 LAS VEGAS,
13 Julio Zumaya (R) 88.81 LAS VEGAS,
14 Ariel Calles (R) 88.43 TAMPA BAY,
15 Philip Coleridge (R) 87.38 RICHMOND,
16 Frank Burton (R) 87.28 CHARLOTTE,
17 Albert Garcia (R) 87.17 TOLEDO,
18 Jair Bonilla (R) 86.99 BURLINGTON,
19 Bono Larkin (R) 86.78 HUNTINGTON,
20 Ken Brantley (L) 86.21 OTTAWA,
21 Todd Corcoran (L) 85.96 COLUMBUS,
22 Roy Washington (R) 85.92 PORTLAND,
23 Boomer O’Sullivan (L) 85.54 CINCINNATI,
24 Mitch Morehead (R) 85.08 TRENTON,
25 Ben Sherman (L) 84.43 SAN FRANCISCO
Ginobili has punched in every teams pitcher into a spreadsheet and using his secret special formula to rank every team’s pitching staff. Let him know what you think of his ratings in the comments!
OTTAWA 83.89 HUNTINGTON 78.02 TOLEDO 73.45 BURLINGTON 73.08 LAS VEGAS 72.88 COLUMBUS 70.05 SCOTTSDALE 69.81 NASHVILLE 69.58 RIChMOND 69.51 KANSAS CITY 69.12 CINCINNATTI 68.99 MEXICO CITY 68.52 SAN FRANCISCO 66.98 PORTLAND 66.68 LOS ANGELES 66.65 AUSTIN 66.63 AUGUSTA 66.33 VANCOUVER 66.22 BOSTON 65.79 CHARLOTTE 65.75 FARGO 65.33 TRENTON 65.3 EL PASO 64.89 BOISE 64.73 SCRANTON 63.01 WASHINGTON 62.92 TAMPA BAY 62.54 NEW ORLEANS 62.46 SAN DIEGO 61.78 ROCHESTER 61.47 BALTIMORE 60.98 HONOLULU 59.92
I am going to rank everyone that I believe who is on the ballot who deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. The top 5 of course are who I think deserves to be in on this ballot. Noting the others who are viable may seem to muddy the waters, but I am pretty liberal with who I think should get into the Hall (it would be a big building if I were in charge). I will also admit that I tend to favor career stats over awards. Particuarly since awards like the All Star game, silver slugger, and gold glove are computer generated, I don’t give them as much credence as the sheer numbers. The awards we vote one hold much more weight IMO. Perhaps if we could come to a consensus on the last few we could get more deserving candidates in and hope to get some of those lower on the list in next season. It is because we are always disagreeing over those last few spots that we have a class like this that is just overloaded with talent and deserving candidates where we will probably only get 2 guys in because there are too many to debate.
1. Fernando Neruda If I have to explain this one to you, stop playing HBD because you clearly don’t even know what a baseball looks like.
2. Shawn Radlosky In earnest, we could call this a career achivement award. When you pitch in the same league as Neruda for most of your career, you lose out on Cy Youngs that would have been won in other more normal circumstances.
3. Ryne Magruder Magruder was a great all around player, played all around the field when Honolulu needed him to change positions from season to season, and he stayed one of the best hitters in the NL his entire career. In my opinion, multiple MVPs speaks loudly. Magruder is the best position player on the ballot and I don’t think there really should be a lot of debate about him deserving the HOF.
4. Hal Wagner Closers have had a difficult time getting in the Hall in this world, but I cannot believe that Wagner is not going to be a shoe in. He won a Cy Young as a closer and had some seasons that were down right absurd. He is number 2 on the career saves list at 641 and would be #1 if he had been a closer early on in his career. I want you to think of one name when you think of Wagner: Dennis Eckersley. Eck was a converted starter, won a Cy Young as a closer, was a part of one of the most dominant teams of his era, is among the all time leaders in saves, and had some of the most dominant seasons we have ever seen from a relief pitcher. That’s Hal Wagner. He should be a HOFer just like Eck.
5. Toby Darnell Darnell simply does not get the kind of credit he deserves. He was a the center of the lineup on some great teams. Primarily playing 2B, he finished at .300 (which is a bigger achievement than it gets credit for in this world), over 2500 hits, nearly 400 home runs, over 1400 runs and RBI, and over 200 stolen bases. Now he played alot of his games at other positions, but go around and find another player who played predominately second base who has those kind of offensive numbers. There might be one or two coming through the pipeline right now, but there are none who are retired. If we did an all time BSA team, Darnell would probably garner consideration for the 2B slot on that team.
6. Robin Drew When I started this article, Robin Drew was on my ballot. I just bumped him when taking a closer look at Darnell, but I still firmly believe that Robin Drew without a doubt is a Hall of Famer. A true ace with 230 wins, a Cy Young, and a career 3.11 ERA and 1.19 WHIP have him among the top pitchers ever in the BSA.
7. Dwayne Richard I don’t know why Richards gets absolutely no love. He was an absolutely dominant ace in his era and a part of perhaps the best 1-2 pitching punch this world has ever seen. He doesn’t have gaudy win totals, but when you dig into his numbers you’ll find he’s one of the greatest of all time.
8. Omar Rhodes Rhodes someone always ends up just on the outside looking in on my ballot. It’s probably because he was a 1B and never won an MVP, but Rhodes should be in the Hall. I just don’t think he was as great as the players I have above him.
9.. Luis Canseco I’m somewhat surprised that Canseco hasn’t had more people talk about voting for him. He was one of the premier hitters in the NL for a long time, garnered silver sluggers at 2 different spots, was in 7 all star games, won two world series rings, had over 2400 hits, nearly 400 homers, over 1400 runs and RBI, and hit over .300 for his career. At some point, we have to break the mold of only voting in guys with gaudy power numbers and start to take a closer look at these guys who were just great hitters but didn’t pop out 50 home runs seasons every year.
10. Edwin Sauveur I really like Sauveur, but I think his numbers should be better for making a living in Tacoma for so long. When you look at numbers like his WHIP and ERA, I think you see why he falls distinctly behind guys like Drew and Richard.
11. Felix Sexton I disregard the fact that Sexton wasn’t a “true” shortstop, but that’s probably because I don’t even consider the silver slugger award. His career stats do merit his consideration, but when I look back and I think about him, I don’t really think of Sexton as a great player. His numbers are good for a shortstop, but they have to be better than that to overcome some fo the true sluggers and aces that are ahead of him for me.
12. Tony Bonilla Bonilla is ahed of Herndon because he is a true catcher. He has all the numbers a catcher should have to get into the Hall of Fame, but I doubt he ever gets close because his numbers just aren’t gaudy enough to merit the kind of attention you need to get in.
13. Claude Herndon Herndon is one of the best hitting catchers of all time. Now sometimes I think he tried to field with a bat in his hand, but man could he hit the long ball. He moved around some late in his career, but he was a very good power hitter who achieved that elusive 500 home run mark. If a catcher hit 500 home runs in real life, he’d be a no brainer for the HOF.
14. Bill Grove Grove probably deserves to get in because quality 3B are hard to come by. He’s really got alot of good things on hsi resume, but I just don’t think he has those one or two things that leap off the page at you to get you to really push for him.
Guys who I know will never get in but I still think belong
Sterling Mercker From the early eras of the BSA, he’s still top 5 in batting average. He would have had gaudy hit numbers with a full career.
Emil Wilkinson Wilkinson never really played full time so that black mark will keep him from getting support. Personally I think it shouldn’t be expected for catchers to get the same kind of ABs as other positions. Wilkinson has the only .400 season in BSA history and still stands among the leaders in batting average and OBP
Miguel Tejada He never really got much of a following during his career as he played for some pretty bad teams, but this guy was just a pure hitter. I always thought of him like a Manny Ramirez. He’d have more of a shot than some guys on this list, but he just never got any awards so I don’t think he’ll get a second glance.
Al Lunar I’m completely biased and would never actually vote for him, but Lunar was one of the best hitters in the BSA early on. He’s the guy that I say to myself “If I only had him now for his whole career…” Just a pure hitter, but we have really screwed over the guys from the early years who should get more consideration than they do in my opinion.
Joel Simmons We got him close during a few years with thinner ballots, but Simons has slipped down the all time list as newer pitchers put up bigger numbers. I’d still put him in my Hall, but even I would take some time to think about it.
My apologies on no Wednesday Wrap or preview for the Play In Series. Just got to busy last week to even think about either. I’ll offer some insight on the play in series as I preview the upcoming DCS.
AL #1 Ottawa Pride versus #5 Portland Razor Clams
Portland was not on anyone’s radar to start the season after a few down seasons and the move from Tacoma, but they took control of the West early on and have been part of the playoff picture all season. San Fransisco pulled off an amazing end to the season to knock them from the top of the AL West, but Portland easily handled division champion Boston in a 3 game sweep to have the “privilege” of facing Ottawa. It does not take a genius to see that Ottawa will be the favorite in every series they are in, so the question is how does Portland upset Ottawa? The only concievable path I see is some remarkable starting pitching performances – the great playoff equalizer. On paper, Ottawa is better in every facet, but Portand is pretty solid defensive team and it’s top 2 starters, Miguel and Jimmie Hernandez are capable of doing something amazing. If they c an take the first 2 games, Portland might be able to pull it off. But with their pitching, I do not think a come from behind series victory is really likely. My prediction is Ottawa in 4.
AL #2 San Fransisco versus #3 Nashville Redbirds
This is the series to watch in this round as these might be the hottest 2 teams in baseball. Nashville won 11 in a row and has won 12 of 13 games, the only loss coming in game 3 of the Play in Series in 18 innings courtesy of a Marvin Piper walk off homer. San Fran won 6 of 7 to end the season and take the West division title and the #2 seed from Portland. Can Nashville stay this hot against a rested San Fransisco? In my opinion, Nashville has more talent but they don’t have veteran leadership like Ben Sherman. San Fran has home field advantage which will be huge for them. I think Nashville is the better team and the hotter team, so I want to pick them. And if this series ends early, it will be Nashville winning it. But I see this series going 5 games and with a game 5 in the Bay with Ben Sherman pitching, I’ll go with San Fran. San Fransisco in 5.
NL #1 Toledo Black Sheep verse #5 Augusta Warriors
Augusta was in the driver’s seat for the number 1 seed in the NL for a bulk of the season, but fell behind to Burlington towards the end of the season and ended up being a wild card. That’s bad news for Toledo. Being the #1 seed in the NL is never a good thing because that means you have to beat two of the better teams to make it to the Series since either Burlington or Augusta is the the top wild card. Toledo actually had their best record ever this season and were 4 games better than last season, but on paper their offense was not as powerful as last year’s team. Augusta has the better middle of the order with Juan Park and John Clark, but Toledo’s lineup 1 to 8 is overall more dangerous. Toledo has a deeper starting rotation but neither team really has that shutdown top of the line starter. Toledo might have the best bullpen in the BSA, but Augusta has the better 9th inning man in Walter Davanon. This series could go any way, but Augusta had no problem scoring on Toledo this season so I see Augusta taking this in 4 games with a lot of runs.
NL #2 Burlington Ents versus #3 Boise Russets
If pitching wins in the playoffs, Burlington is always at an advantage because they have the best pitcher in the game in Rudy Tabaka. Being in a pitcher’s park helps, but Tabaka is just that good. In a short series, you basically have to try and figure out how to win the 3 games he isn’t pitching in. Boise always seems to be a tough out in the playoffs and really gutted out the last 2 wins in the play in series win in 4 games over Washington D.C., but seeing them as a 3 seed to Burlington’s 2 seed makes this seem alot closer than it is. Burlington is 21 games better than Boise, who would not have been in the playoffs had they not won their division. Boise has some great young players and I see them winning the West for many seasons to come, but Burlington takes this series in a 3 game sweep.
I do not gamble at all, so I would make a horrible oddsmaker, but here are the odds for each team to win the World Series as I see them.
Ottawa 2-1 (will be the favorite in every series they play no matter who they play)
Burlington 4 to 1 (Tabaka makes them a favorite in the NL, but the thought of having to beat Toledo/Augusta and then Ottawa is a tall order)
Nashville 5 to 1 (I know I picked against them, but they are the hottest team in baseball and have a lineup that could potentially score with Ottawa)
San Fransisco 6 to 1 (In spite of Ottawa standing in the way, the winner of the AL will probably be less beaten up than the winner of the NL. Having future hall of famer Ben Sherman and former Cy Young winner Harry Feliz makes them look good in the playoffs too)
Toledo and Augusta 8 to 1 (they might have better teams than teams ahead of them, but they have to beat the other team in a short series, beat Burlington and Tabake in a 7 game series and then beat Ottawa in the Series. If that’s their road to victory, it’s not a safe bet)
Portland 20 to 1 (If they beat Ottawa somehow, their odds will skyrocket)
Boise 25 to 1 (Boise would have to beat Burlington, Toledo/Augusta and Ottawa. They’ve got their shot by being in the playoffs, but it’s a long, long shot)
Sorry everyone, I got this started yesterday but didn’t get it finished so my numbers are going to be a little different than what may be true right now since some of it was from yesterday morning and some of it is from this morning. Hope you still enjoy it!
1. NL Playoff Picture At just past the 130 game mark, there are really only 3 questions left in the NL playoff picture. The first is the seeding. Toledo still is in the first spot with Augusta in the second spot. They could easily flip spots, but Burlington has the opportunity to overcome Augusta and move into one of those top two spots too. The second question is the NL West. LA and boise are still fighting it out and LA sits at 3 games back now. With their owner back and engaged, LA has the chance to make things interesting down the stretch. The final question is the last wild card spot. Richmond and Washington DC are tied for the spot. Their series starting on Monday could decide that spot. Columbus and the loser of the West still are in the race, but Richmond and DC are the odds on favorites.
So my prediction isn’t changing for the NL: Augusta, Toledo, Boise, Tampa Bay, Burlington, Washington DC with Toledo and Burlington meeting in the championships series and Burlington going to the series.
2. AL Playoff Picture The AL still has a lot of questions to answer, but the picture is a little clearer. Ottawa is still the one for sure, winning the North and being the #1 seed. Huntington is trying to make the East interesting, but Boston still has a solid 4 game lead. Portland is still leading the West, but San Francisco has gained on them and is only 3 games back. Kansas City moved ahead in the South but El Paso and Nashville are still both within reach of the division title. Portland and Kansas City are then fighting for that 2nd spot and the bye, but it’s close enough that Nashville, San Fransisco, or El Paso could make a move to that spot if someone falters or they have a hot week. The Wild Card Race is really now between San Fransisco, Nashville, and El Paso, but Charlotte, Vegas, or Huntington are still within range.
So the AL really now looks like it will be 6 out of 7 teams and it is that last spot that is up for grabs. So my prediction for what 6 teams make it are Ottawa, Portland, Kansas City, Boston, San Fransisco, and Nashville with El Paso being the one team left out. My other prediction is that this will probably look different next week. 3. League Leaders Batting Average and OBP Brian Kim is still leading the way in the AL at .353 but Kaito Pan is right behind him at .339. Pan is also leading OBP at .420 but teammate Christopher Posey is just one point behind at .419. In the NL, Augusta teammates Juan Park (.333) and John Clark (.330) are competing for the batting title. OBP is safely led by Honolulu’s Brian Canseco at .418 with Ken Victorino (.412) and Antonio Feng (.410) trailing behind.
4. League Leaders Home Runs and RBI Huntington recently acquired the AL Home run leader in Frank Winchester . Three other sluggers are over 40 homers, including Huntington’s Tony Nicholas (41), Marvin Piper (40), and Angel Sanchez (43). KC’s Garrett Thames leads the way with 113 RBI followed by Posey at 111 and Christopher Huff 110. In the NL, Juan Park leads in both home runs at 55 and RBI at 136. Washington’s Polin Castilla is second in both categories with 47 homers and 111 runs driven in.
5. League Leaders Wins and Saves In the AL, Trace Woods has 21 wins and has pretty much secured the league lead in that area. Ottawa’s Tony Tanaka (18) and San Fran’s Ben Sherman (17) also have a shot at 20 wins. In the AL with saves, Ottawa’s Ken Brantley with 35 saves is being chased by Syracuse’s Pepe Granados with 34. In the Senior Circuit, Rudy Tabaka has 24 wins to lead all of baseball and the next closest total is Cookie Mota with 17. Augusta’s Walter DaVanon has 44 saves on the season to lead everyone with Jair Bonilla Yorman Canseco trailing far behind at 35.
6. League Leaders WHIP and ERA In the AL, Ottawa’s Tanaka leads with a .96 WHIP and no one else is under 1. Sherman is the only one close at 1.01. Carlos Rios and Tanaka are tied in ERA at 2.72. As for the NL, Tabaka leads both WHIP (.79) and ERA (1.53). Ariel Calles is second in WHIP at .90 and Ed Moyer second in ERA at .244
7. NL Triple Crowns – If you put two and two together reading those league leaders, it means that Juan Park and Rudy Tabaka are both set to win their respective triple crowns. Park’s only competition is really in batting average with his teammmate John Clark as his leads in homers and RBI are secure. It would take an absolutely epic meltdown for Tabaka to have anyone come close to him in any category. To put those seasons in perspective, look at all time numbers. Tabaka is having perhaps the best pitching season ever. He will set the single season mark in WHIP by a pretty substantial margin, a top 5 season in ERA, and a top 5 season in wins (potentially the second best total ever, but he won’t get to Roy Hardy numbers, who had 30 wins in season 7). And by the way, Tabaka leads the league in ks (230) with 45 more than the next closest pitcher. Park’s season is no where near Tabaka’s historically and I honestly have no idea how many players have won triple crowns, but here are the guys I found who hit over .330 with over 50 homers and over 130 RBI: Ugueth Moya , Dan Thompson, Alfonso Cruz, and Rusty Laker. That’s pretty solid company to keep.
8. Record Breaker Watch Luther Aldred and Alfonso Cruz are the only 2 hitters in BSA history with over 3000 hits. Is there any current hitter who has the chance to join that club? Christopher Posey looks like he has a shot. Last season, he set the single season hits mark with 230 and the season before he had a top 5 all time season with 224. His total is down this season, but at 173 his pace should put him around the 205 to 210 range. If he does that, it will put him right over 2700 career hits. Entering next season at age 35, those last 300 hits come a lot harder than they seem. While Posey is declining, he is still the AL MVP favorite this season and doesn’t seem to be slowing that significantly statistically. The way things looks, Posey should become the all time hits leader during season 30 and put his career total to a place that might be out of reach for anyone else.
9. Hall of Fame Question We all love the Hall of Fame so I wanted to bring up a random player each week to debate whether they are Hall of Fame worthy or not. It’s not a debate as to whether they will get the votes to get into the HOF, but whether they belong in our Hall. Some of them may be more clear cut than others, but it’s fun to debate anyways. Part of Ottawa’s incredible offense this season has been 38 year old veteran slugger Andruw Hartzell. This may very well be his last season in the majors, though he can still hit well enough that he may find his way onto a ML bench next season. He is a career .326 hitter, hitting over .300 in 16 of 17 ML seasons. He has 471 homers and over 1600 RBI, with 9 season of 30 plus homers and 7 seasons of 100 plus RBI. He won the AL MVP award in season 17, made 4 all teams, won 10 Silver Sluggers, and has two World Series rings with hopes for a third one this season. Oh, and he played 10 of his seasons in the worst park for hitters in HBD (Tacoma). I think he is a clear Hall of Famer, but my Hall of Fame would need constant expansion for all the guys I think deserve to be in it. What do you think? Is Hartzell a Hall of Famer?
10. Back to Reality I absolutely hate the new MLB wild card game. While it carries with it the excitement of a game 7 and I understand the draw to let one more team in the playoffs, letting one game decide a playoff in baseball just seems ludicrous. It’s not just because the Reds lost to Pittsburgh, but I also live near Cleveland and saw everything surrounding that game. While all of Cleveland was excited for that game, they should have been preparing for a 5 game series against Boston. They earned that spot over 162 games and to throw that away for TV ratings and one more night of ticket sales to me belittles the hard work and achievements of those players. The Reds deserved to lose and Pittsburgh deserved to play a series so I’m not super upset by that, but I feel for Cleveland fans today who haven’t even realized yet that if it were last season, they’d get at least 2 more games for their season.